Supplements is a noisy category. Bright tubs, big claims, and a lot of products that do very little. The honest truth is that most people building a routine need a short list of well-understood basics, not a cupboard full of powders. Here is a straightforward starter, with dependable products for each job.
Protein: the foundation
Protein is where most routines start, and a good whey is the simplest way to hit a daily target. Optimum Nutrition’s Gold Standard 100% Whey is the long-standing benchmark, consistent, mixes cleanly, and comes in a long list of flavours. If a milky shake feels heavy, a lighter juice-style option like Clear Whey does the same job with a different texture. For anyone avoiding dairy, a plant-based protein covers it.
A word on price, because this article ends by telling you a kilogram of whey is a kilogram of whey.
Optimum Nutrition is not the value pick, and our own comparison page will tell you so within one click. On price per 100g it sits in the bottom half of every whey we track, and the Clear Whey range sits at the very bottom of it. The best-priced whey on that page costs well under half what Gold Standard does, for the same gram of protein.
We are recommending it anyway, and here is the honest reason. Gold Standard is the reference point, the tub most people have used and the one whose taste and mixability everything else gets measured against, in a long list of flavours. It is stocked at Boots, which means you can pick it up today rather than wait for a delivery threshold to make sense. That is what you are paying the premium for, and it is a real thing to want.
If what you want is the most protein for the money, do not buy this. Compare every whey by price per 100g and start at the top of the list.
Creatine: the most proven, and the most over-complicated
Creatine monohydrate is one of the most researched supplements there is, and the plain version does the job. Ignore the pricier ‘advanced’ forms unless you have a specific reason; straightforward monohydrate, like Optimum Nutrition’s, is the sensible pick. This is exactly the kind of product where comparing by unit price pays off, because the same nutrient varies enormously in price by brand.
The extras, only if you need them
Electrolytes are worth it if you train hard or sweat heavily; a pre-workout is optional and personal; collagen sits more at the wellness end than the performance one. None of these are essential to start, and it is better to nail protein and creatine first than to buy a long list on day one.
How to choose without overpaying
The single most useful habit is to compare by what a nutrient actually costs, not by brand recognition or tub size. A kilogram of whey is a kilogram of whey whoever makes it, and the price per 100g can vary several times over for the same thing. Our supplement comparison pages rank by exactly that, so you can see where a brand sits before you buy. We would rather you bought a short list of proven basics than a cupboard of powders.
Build your starter routine and compare it in one place
Add your protein, creatine and extras, and see the best value way to buy the whole basket with delivery counted. Or rank a single type by price per 100g, creatine or plant protein.
Compare prices →Prices vary across retailers and change regularly. Use FindMyBasket for live prices. FindMyBasket may earn a small commission when you shop through our links, at no extra cost to you.